The Reinstein Varsity Tournament is a continuation of the former New Trier Varsity tournament, which started in 2005.
2025
The 2025 tournament will be held Saturday, December 20 at Barrington High School in Barrington, Illinois.
2024
The 2024 tournament was held Saturday, December 14 at Barrington High School in Barrington, Illinois.
2023
The 2023 tournament was held Saturday, December 16 at Barrington High School in Barrington, Illinois.
The Über-Competitive Division (24 teams) was won by Barrington High School A. The Standard Division (47 eligible teams) was won by Springfield High School (Springfield, Illinois).
2022
The 2022 tournament was held Saturday, December 17 at Barrington High School in Barrington, Illinois.
The Über-Competitive Division (16 teams) was won by Barrington High School A. The Standard Division (54 teams) was won by Timothy Christian Schools A (Elmhurst, Illinois).
2021
The 2021 tournament was held Saturday, December 18 at Barrington High School in Barrington, Illinois.
The Über-Competitive Division (16 teams) was jointly won by Carmel High School A (Indiana) and Buffalo Grove High School A. The Standard Division (36 teams) was won by Timothy Christian Schools (Elmhurst, Illinois).